Boil & Bake

Boil & Bake in Costa Mesa is redefining what a bagel shop can be, blending the heart of classic New York-style bagels with a fresh, Californian twist. Nestled at 270 Bristol St #114, this vibrant spot is a beloved destination for locals craving that perfect bagel experience elevated by thoughtful, high-quality ingredients and inventive combinations.

The star here is undoubtedly their bagels — whether you’re drawn to the Fully Loaded Lox and Bagel piled high with silky salmon, cream cheese, capers, and fresh herbs, or the Santa Monica sandwich that brims with tender salmon lox and juicy heirloom tomatoes. Each bite bursts with layers of flavor, from the tangy cream cheeses like Horseradish or Scallion Chive to the nutty crunch of Toasted Sesame Seeds. The Blueberry and Breakfast Bagels offer sweet and savory options alike, complemented perfectly by freshly squeezed juices or a robust cup of their Common Room Roasters drip coffee.

Patrons rave about the bold, well-curated menu items such as the Garden Bagel - lush with salted cucumber, radish, and sprouts - and the Pizza Bagel Special, which turns a humble bagel into a melty, savory delight. For those who love a hearty start, the Breakfast Sandwich or Burrito, alongside sides like Housemade Apple Compote, effortlessly satisfy morning cravings with fresh, vibrant flavors.

The atmosphere at Boil & Bake carries an inviting, casual California vibe. Though the buzz and popularity can mean waiting in line, guests agree the experience and the taste more than justify the anticipation. Customers have shared glowing endorsements, with one Brooklyn transplant saying, “I moved here from NYC and no longer long for NYC bagels. This place more than hits the spot,” signaling the quality and authenticity of Boil & Bake’s offerings. Another customer fondly called it “the best bagel ever” and recommended waiting in line because it’s absolutely worth it—proof of the shop’s devoted following.

Some mention the bagel itself can be a bit tough, especially when ordered to-go, but the flavors and thoughtful composition of each sandwich more than compensate for that slight texture critique. Pricing is on the higher end, but many customers feel the exceptional ingredients and crafted taste justify the cost, calling it a true local favorite deserving of its loyal fan base.

Whether you’re a bagel connoisseur or simply in search of a fresh, inventive breakfast or lunch, Boil & Bake delivers a uniquely satisfying experience crafted to leave a lasting impression. It’s no surprise that fans are already eager for expansion and wishing for a second location to bring these standout bagels to even more communities.

For a bagel shop that pushes the boundaries of tradition while honoring classic flavors, Boil & Bake is a must-visit gem in Costa Mesa.